Skip to content
SEO2026

Editorial quality · trustworthiness · YMYL risk

E-E-A-T and YMYL Content Audit: Evidence, Authors, Claims and Editorial QA

Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness and Trustworthiness describe qualities of useful, reliable content, with trust especially important. They are not an accessible numeric Google 'E-E-A-T score'. YMYL covers subjects where misinformation could materially affect health, financial stability, safety or wider wellbeing. Responsible content production should reflect those actual risks.

01 / 6

Make authorship verifiable rather than decorative

A genuine byline should link to an author page explaining relevant experience, specific work and sources the reader can inspect. Invented credentials, fabricated headshots and stock-photo 'experts' undermine trust, even when accompanied by Article schema.

First-hand technical SEO experience supports hands-on search analysis, not clinical treatment or personalised investment advice. Expertise is contextual: a relevant medical or financial claim may need professional validation outside the writer's domain.

Acceptance criteria

  • An identifiable author has accurate professional information.
  • Credentials are never fabricated or transferred between disciplines.

02 / 6

Disclose how evidence and automation were used

Distinguish official guidance, observational research, controlled first-hand tests and interpretation. Label demonstration data as examples. If you did not directly perform a case study, do not write that you measured actual client results.

AI assistance can support organisation, editing and finding inconsistencies, but factual accuracy, real sources, legal permissions and the final publication remain human responsibilities. Disclose substantive automation when readers would reasonably need to understand the method.

Acceptance criteria

  • Material claims can be traced to credible original evidence.
  • Synthetic examples are never presented as real observations.

03 / 6

Classify YMYL risk at the claim level

Ask what would happen if a reader relied on a wrong statement. Some advice could cause injury, harmful financial decisions, legal consequences or safety risks; those claims require a greater standard of confidence and accountability.

A technical guide about canonical URLs does not automatically become high-risk because it mentions costs. A checkout-security guide may still touch financial safety. Evaluate the purpose and consequence of a specific instruction rather than applying a blanket YMYL label to all SEO articles.

Acceptance criteria

  • Potential real-world harm is described for sensitive claims.
  • Appropriate specialist review is planned where required.

04 / 6

Verify changing facts and contradictions

Record important claim text, source URL, source publication/update date and whether evidence is sufficient. If two credible sources disagree, explain uncertainties instead of silently selecting the convenient figure.

For time-sensitive laws, clinical recommendations, vendor billing or API behaviour, set a real review process. Changing an HTML date alone does not mean a document was substantively updated and is not a legitimate signal of expertise.

Acceptance criteria

  • Risky claims undergo independent fact checking.
  • Last-modified dates correspond to meaningful editorial work.

05 / 6

Use meaningful semantic HTML and honest schema

An article with a true H1/H2 hierarchy, semantic navigation, figures and captions, properly scoped table headers, links to sources and a real author page is easier for visitors and machines to interpret.

Article schema can describe an authentic author and page. Do not add fake review ratings, medical reviewer credentials, FAQ rich-result markup or published dates just to chase visibility. Structured data must reflect the visible facts and applicable eligibility rules.

Acceptance criteria

  • Article markup agrees with displayed information.
  • No fictional reviewers, ratings or freshness signals.

06 / 6

Run an accountable corrections workflow

Provide a way to flag errors, record major changes, and decide whether a correction, withdrawal or follow-up review is needed. High-risk recommendations should be cleared by an actual appropriate expert before publication.

A useful evidence register contains URL, claim, original source, possible harm, author, qualified reviewer if applicable, review date, outcome and correction note. This is stronger than a numerical trust score because every decision has a traceable basis.

Acceptance criteria

  • Readers can report errors.
  • Corrections and appropriate specialist reviews are documented.

Copy and adapt

Copyable editorial claim-verification register

A 'reviewer' field must represent a real qualified person. Sample data uses placeholders and does not represent an audited medical page.

csv
url,claim,topic,risk,original_source,author,qualified_reviewer,evidence_checked,review_status,meaningful_update,correction
https://example.com/seo,canonical is a signal,technical SEO,low,Google documentation,real author,not needed,2026-10-15,verified,2026-10-15,
https://example.com/medical,medical advice,health YMYL,high,clinical guideline,real author,qualified reviewer needed,,pending,,

Verify completion

0/12

Mark only steps you verified on your own site. These checkboxes reset on reload and do not certify the result.

Common failures and fixes

An agency sells an 'E-E-A-T score of 95'

Cause: Google does not provide such a public per-URL quality metric.

Fix: Replace the score with verifiable source, authorship and review evidence.

An AI-generated expert portrait appears on a medical article

Cause: The published reviewer identity is deceptive and the review never occurred.

Fix: Remove invented attribution; engage and credit an actually qualified reviewer where appropriate.

Beautiful design conceals claims without citations

Cause: Decorative trust elements substitute for checking factual accuracy.

Fix: Verify important claims with dependable sources and describe uncertain findings honestly.

Questions people ask

Does Google issue E-E-A-T certificates?

No. There is no official purchasable E-E-A-T certificate or publicly assigned score.

Is every SEO article a YMYL article?

No. The risk depends on the page's actual advice and its potential real-world consequences.

Must a writer pretend never to have used AI?

No. The method should be truthful and the final factual accountability explicit. Disclose meaningful automation when context warrants it.

Does Article schema make a page authoritative?

No. Schema describes visible information; it is not evidence of expertise on its own.

Method, limits and source evidence

Reviewed October 15, 2026 against Google Search Central's people-first content guidance. This is an editorial QA process, not a Google ranking score.

No fabricated medical, financial or legal qualifications are used. All example URLs are educational placeholders.

Relevant book discussions include chapters 15–16, 18, 20, 27–28 and 37.

Found a factual error? Contact the author.

Read the original book chapters

These subjects are explored in the original SEO 2026 book. Full chapters are freely readable with citations, original tables and figures.

Explore another real problem

All SEO playbooks